Running Django with FastCGI or with mod_python

which would you recommend? which is faster, reliable? apache mod_python or nginx/lighttpd FastCGI?


Asked by: Lenny274 | Posted: 06-12-2021






Answer 1

I've done both, and Apache/mod_python tended to be easier to work with and more stable. But these days I've jumped over to Apache/mod_wsgi, which is everything I've ever wanted and more:

  • Easy management of daemon processes.
  • As a result, much better process isolation (running multiple sites in the same Apache config with mod_python almost always ends in trouble -- environment variables and C extensions leak across sites when you do that).
  • Easy code reloads (set it up right and you can just touch the .wsgi file to reload instead of restarting Apache).
  • More predictable resource usage. With mod_python, a given Apache child process' memory use can jump around a lot. With mod_wsgi it's pretty stable: once everything's loaded, you know that's how much memory it'll use.

Answered by: Blake802 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 2

lighttpd with FastCGI will be nominally faster, but really the time it takes to run your python code and any database hits it does is going to absolutely dwarf any performance benefit you get between web servers.

mod_python and apache will give you a bit more flexibility feature-wise if you want to write code outside of django that does stuff like digest auth, or any fancy HTTP header getting/setting. Perhaps you want to use other builtin features of apache such as mod_rewrite.

If memory is a concern, staying away form apache/mod_python will help a lot. Apache tends to use a lot of RAM, and the mod_python code that glues into all of the apache functionality occupies a lot of memory-space as well. Not to mention the multiprocess nature of apache tends to eat up more RAM, as each process grows to the size of it's most intensive request.

Answered by: Hailey588 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 3

Nginx with mod_wsgi

Answered by: Emily719 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 4

I'm using it with nginx. not sure if it's really faster, but certainly less RAM/CPU load. Also it's easier to run several Django processes and have nginx map each URL prefix to a different socket. still not taking full advantage of nginx's memcached module, but first tests show huge speed advantage.

Answered by: Gianna630 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 5

There's also mod_wsgi, it seems to be faster than mod_python and the daemon mode operates similar to FastCGI

Answered by: Michael132 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 6

Personally I've had it working with FastCGI for some time now (6 months or so) and the response times 'seem' quicker when loading a page that way vs mod___python. The critical reason for me though is that I couldn't see an obvious way to do multiple sites from the same apache / mod_python install whereas FastCGI was a relative no-brainer.

I've not conducted any particularly thorough experiments though :-)

[Edit] Speaking from experience though, setting up FastCGI can be a bit of a pain the first time around. I keep meaning to write a guide..!

Answered by: Tara995 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Answer 7

I'd recommend WSGI configurations; I keep meaning to ditch apache, but there is always some legacy app on the server that seems to require it. Additionally, the WSGI app ecology is very diverse, and it allows neat tricks such as daisy-chaining WSGI "middleware" between the server and the app.

However, there are currently known issues with some apps and apache mod_wsgi, particularly some ctypes apps, so be wary if you are trying to run, say, geodjango which uses ctypes extensively. I'm currently working around those issues by going back to fastcgi myself.

Answered by: Cherry492 | Posted: 07-01-2022



Similar questions

python - Django, mod_python, apache and wacky sessions

I am running a Django through mod_python on Apache on a linux box. I have a custom authentication backend, and middleware that requires authentication for all pages, except static content. My problem is that after I log in, I will still randomly get the log in screen now and again. It seems to me that each apache process has it's own python process, which in turn has it's own internals. So as long as I get served b...


python - Failed to get separate instances of a class under mod_python

I'm trying to run some python code under Apache 2.2 / mod_python 3.2.8. Eventually the code does os.fork() and spawns 2 separate long-run processes. Each of those processes has to create a separate instance of a class in order to avoid any possible collision in the parallel flow. class Foo(object): pass kidprocs = [] for kid in ('kid1', 'kid2'): pid = os.fork() if pid: # parent kidprocs.a...


python - How to access to the root path in a mod_python directory?

In my Apache webserver I put this: <Directory /var/www/MYDOMAIN.com/htdocs> SetHandler mod_python PythonHandler mod_python.publisher PythonDebug On </Directory> Then I have a handler.py file with an index function. When I go to MYDOMAIN.com/handler.py, I see a web page produced by the index function (just a plain vanilla HTML page). Every other page is of th...


python - How do I modify sys.path from .htaccess to allow mod_python to see Django?

The host I'm considering for hosting a Django site has mod_python installed, but does not have Django. Django's INSTALL file indicates that I can simply copy the django directory to Python's site-packages directory to install Django, so I suspect that it might be possible to configure Python / mod_python to look for it elsewhere (namely my user space) by modifying sys.path, but I don't know how to change it from .htaccess ...


php - mod_php vs mod_python

Why mod_python is oop but mod_php is not ? Example :We go to www.example.com/dir1/dir2 if you use mod_python apache opens www/dir1.py and calls dir2 method but if you use php module apache opens www/dir1/dir2/index.php


python - How do I upload a file with mod_python?

I want to create a simple file upload form and I must be completely incapable. I've read docs and tutorials,but for some reason, I'm not getting the submitted form data. I wrote the smallest amount of code I could to test and it still isn't working. Any ideas what's wrong? def index(): html = ''' <html> <body> <form id="fileUpload" action="./result" method="post"> ...


python - mod_python publisher and pretty URLs

I am new to Python (I am getting out of PHP because of how increasingly broken it is), and I am racing through porting my old code. One thing: I have a file /foo.py with functions index() and bar(), so, with the publisher I can access http://domain/foo/bar and http://domain/foo as the documentatio...


python - Configure Apache to recover from mod_python errors

This question already has an answer here:


python - mod_python caching of variables

I'm using mod_python to run Trac in Apache. I'm developing a plugin and am not sure how global variables are stored/cached. I am new to python and have googled the subject and found that mod_python caches python modules (I think). However, I would expect that cache to be reset when the web service is restarted, but it doesn't appear to be. I'm saying this becasue I have a global variable that is a ...


django - Different behavior of python logging module when using mod_python

We have a nasty problem where we see that the python logging module is behaving differently when running with mod_python on our servers. When executing the same code in the shell, or in django with the runserver command or with mod_wsgi, the behavior is correct: import logging logger = logging.getLogger('site-errors') logging.debug('logger=%s' % (logger.__dict__)) logging.debug('logger.parent=%s' % (logger....






Still can't find your answer? Check out these communities...



PySlackers | Full Stack Python | NHS Python | Pythonist Cafe | Hacker Earth | Discord Python



top